SCOTT DETROW, HOST:
Shortly after the midterms, Vice President JD Vance took to social media to explain why Democrats won. He blamed the war in Iran, America's relationship with Israel and economic issues. Notably absent from that list, the historic immigration crackdown the Trump administration has led for 18 months. But overwhelmingly, economists say mass deportations are an economic issue. NPR's Jasmine Garsd reports.
JASMINE GARSD, BYLINE: So for decades, this has been the line of thinking of conservative politicians - immigrants steal jobs and they lower wages for American workers. And for decades, economists have said that's just not how it works.
CHLOE EAST: The research is extremely clear that, overwhelmingly, immigration is good for the economy and good for U.S.-born workers.
GARSD: That's Chloe East. She teaches economics at the University of Colorado Boulder. She has studied the effects of mass deportations on the U.S. since the Obama administration.
EAST: The reality is the number of jobs is completely a function of the size of the population. Immigrants are not just workers. They're also consumers. They eat out at restaurants. They get haircuts. They go to the grocery store. And when there is a mass deportation campaign, that means there are fewer people eating out at restaurants and getting haircuts, and that causes fewer jobs for everybody.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
FRANCISCO MARTE: Fight and we fight (ph).
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Fight and we fight.
GARSD: New York City has been hard hit by immigration crackdowns in recent months. Francisco Marte owns this corner store in the Bronx.
MARTE: (Speaking Spanish).
GARSD: "ICE has been attacking people everywhere," he says. "People are scared. They're not going out. It's done tremendous damage to the economy." Marte estimates that his store has taken a 25- to 30% hit since Trump took office.
We reached out to the White House to ask about this. In a statement to NPR, spokesperson Lauren Bis said, quote, "removing these criminals from the streets makes community safer for business owners and customers." But according to the latest data, around 70% of people in immigration detention don't have a criminal conviction. Marte says he voted for President Trump. He even keeps a photo by the register of the time he met Trump at a campaign stop. He says he's disappointed.
MARTE: (Speaking Spanish).
GARSD: "We've seen agents in front of schools. They've taken kids, pregnant women, older people, people who've been here for 15, 20 years working, paying taxes." He says he's even had family members detained.
But there's another number analysts are talking about - the growing amount of people who, overnight, find themselves undocumented.
PHILLIP CONNOR: So that's a very significant, large portion of the workforce.
GARSD: Phillip Connor is a researcher at FWD.us, an immigration advocacy group. His new study found that as of August, over 1.2 million immigrants have lost their status since Trump took office, meaning they were here legally with permission to work until the administration canceled protections, like, for example, temporary protected status, or TPS.
CONNOR: More than 200,000 construction workers, more than 150,000 leisure and hospitality workers, even nearly 100,000 in healthcare and education in that industry.
GARSD: According to his research, by the end of this year, that will mean $47 billion in lost annual economic activity and $13 billion lost in annual taxes - that's billion with a B. And so Connor says immigration policy is very much an economic issue.
Jasmine Garsd, NPR News, New York. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.