A Service of UA Little Rock
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Jury finds man guilty in retrial over devastating 2025 Palisades fire in Los Angeles

SCOTT SIMON, HOST:

Palisades Fire was one of the most deadly and destructive in California history, tearing through Los Angeles County last year and killing 12 people and burning nearly 7,000 homes and businesses. Now a jury has convicted the man accused of starting the fire. This was a retrial because an earlier trial ended with a deadlocked jury. Steve Futterman has covered both and joins us now from LA. Steve, thanks so much for being with us.

STEVE FUTTERMAN, BYLINE: My pleasure, Scott.

SIMON: Tell us more about the jury's verdict yesterday.

FUTTERMAN: Well, it came on the third day of deliberations. The jury found Jonathan Rinderknecht guilty on two separate counts. Now, this trial involved the Palisades Fire, but it also involved a second fire, the Lachman Fire. Rinderknecht, who was an Uber driver at the time, was accused of starting the Lachman Fire just past midnight on January 1, last year. Now, the flames from that fire were put out, but it smoldered underground for a week, then reemerged a week later as that deadly Palisades Fire.

The prosecution's case centered on the fact that Rinderknecht was in the exact area where the fire was ignited at the time it was ignited. He was portrayed as an angry person, as a loner. The defense argued that the fire was started by New Year's fireworks, but there was a big problem - Rinderknecht himself told law enforcement before he was charged that he never saw or heard fireworks.

SIMON: Now, of course, a different jury earlier this year split 10-to-2 in favor of acquittal that led to a mistrial. How did jurors reach a different decision?

FUTTERMAN: Well, one of the charges was adjusted to focus only on the Lachman Fire. Some of the jurors in the first trial said they had problems with that argument that the Lachman Fire became the Palisades Fire. The prosecution also streamlined its case with less focus on personal attacks on Rinderknecht. Now, after the verdict yesterday, juror No. 3 spoke to reporters. His name is Cameron (ph). He declined to give his last name for privacy reasons.

CAMERON: The strongest evidence was the defendant's own testimony stating that he was up on a hill, didn't smell a fire, didn't see fireworks. It was a clear, calm night. You know, no one else was on the Hill that day. Logically, things start pointing towards him.

SIMON: Steve, what's the reaction been from those involved in the case?

FUTTERMAN: Well, the prosecutors were quite pleased with the decision. This is the first U.S. attorney in Los Angeles, Bill Essayli.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

BILL ESSAYLI: All of us remember the devastating images of people fleeing their homes, the fire destroying structures. And the question at the time was, who is responsible? And now we have the answer to that question.

FUTTERMAN: I also spoke briefly with Joel Rinderknecht. He's the father of the defendant. He accused the prosecution of simply looking for someone to blame.

JOEL RINDERKNECHT: They want him to be convicted, and it didn't matter. Ethics didn't matter. Misleading statement didn't matter. False statement didn't matter. The truth didn't matter.

FUTTERMAN: Do you believe your son is innocent?

RINDERKNECHT: Oh, I know he's innocent. It's not just a belief. I know he's innocent.

FUTTERMAN: And there was also a reaction from some of those directly impacted by the Palisades Fire. Traci Park is the councilwoman who represents Pacific Palisades.

TRACI PARK: Yes, it does provide some measure of accountability. On the other hand, there is no amount of courtroom justice that will ever undo the devastation.

SIMON: And, Steve, when's sentencing?

FUTTERMAN: Sentencing is next March. Rinderknecht faces up to 20 years on each of the two counts. And, Scott, this does not end the legal battles from the Palisades Fire. There are still numerous civil lawsuits charging the city, the state, the fire department and utilities with negligence. Those cases could take years to resolve.

SIMON: Steve Futterman in Los Angeles. Thanks so much.

FUTTERMAN: Thanks, Scott.

(SOUNDBITE OF ORIGAMIBIRO'S "FRACTURE") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Steve Futterman
Scott Simon is the host of Weekend Edition Saturday and is one of the hosts of NPR's morning news podcast Up First.